New Lift Installation vs Modernisation: Which Is the Smarter Choice?
New Lift Installation vs Modernisation: Which Is the Smarter Choice for Your Building?
When your lift starts slowing down, breaking down, or causing frustration for tenants, a big question comes up: “Should we install a brand-new lift, or is modernisation enough?”
It's a decision almost every building owner or facilities manager faces eventually — and the right answer depends on your lift’s condition, age, usage, and future plans for the building.
At ACE Elevators Northern, we help clients across Yorkshire and Northern England make this choice every week. So let’s walk through the differences, the costs, and how to know which option makes the most sense for you.
When Modernisation Is the Better Choice
In many cases, your lift doesn’t need to be replaced. Modernisation upgrades the major components while keeping the existing structure — giving you a “new” lift without the full installation cost.
Modernisation is usually the smarter option if:
- Your lift is mechanically sound but outdated - Older control panels, motors, or door operators can make a lift unreliable long before the structure wears out.
- You want better energy efficiency - Upgrading to modern motors, LED lighting, and regenerative drives can cut energy use by up to 70%.
- The ride is rough, noisy, or slow - New control systems can completely transform the ride quality — smoother, quieter, and more responsive.
- You need to improve safety or compliance - LOLER recommendations, BS EN 81 safety upgrades, and accessibility improvements can all be addressed through modernisation.
Modernisation is more affordable than a full installation, and downtime is usually shorter. Most buildings see dramatic improvements from targeted upgrades — and many lifts gain another 10–15 years of reliable operation.
When Installing a Brand-New Lift Makes More Sense
There are times, however, when installing a new lift is the only option that truly makes financial or operational sense.
A new lift is often the right choice if:
- Your lift is over 25–30 years old - At this age, parts become harder to source and overall reliability drops significantly.
- Breakdowns are becoming frequent - If repair costs are piling up each year, a new system may be more cost-effective long term.
- Your lift is no longer compliant with modern safety standards - Some older lifts cannot meet BS EN 81 standards without extensive work — making replacement more practical.
- You need higher capacity or faster travel - A new installation allows for bigger cabins, faster speeds, and modern accessibility layouts.
- The building is being refurbished or extended - If you're making major changes, it’s the perfect time to install a new lift designed around your updated building.
While a new lift is a bigger investment, it delivers decades of reliability, better performance, and lower running costs.
Cost Comparison: Modernisation vs New Installation
Costs vary depending on lift type, floors served, and building structure — but here’s a general guide:
Modernisation:
More cost-effective
Reduced downtime
Lower energy use
Extends the life of the existing lift
Ideal for improving reliability and compliance
New Lift Installation
Higher initial investment
Highest performance and energy efficiency
Provides a modern cabin and updated design
Future-proof for 20–30 years
Essential if your lift is beyond economical repair
Most property owners are surprised by how cost-effective modernisation can be, especially when compared with ongoing repair bills.
How to Decide: A Simple Rule of Thumb
At ACE Elevators Northern, we often give clients this simple guideline:
If your lift is under 20–25 years old and structurally sound → modernise it.
If it’s over 25 years old, unreliable, or failing major components → consider a new installation.
Of course, every lift is different — which is why a professional survey is essential.
What ACE Elevators Northern Recommends
We offer both modernisation and full installation services — so our advice is always based on what’s genuinely best for you.
During a survey, we assess:
- The age and condition of your lift
- Breakdown history
- Safety compliance
- Energy efficiency
- Parts availability
- Your building’s layout and usage
- Budget and future plans
Then we give you clear, honest recommendations — no pressure, no upselling, just expert guidance from engineers with more than 30 years of experience.
Ready to Find Out Which Option Is Right for You?
If your lift is causing problems — or you’re planning a refurbishment — now is the perfect time to explore your options.
Whether it’s modernisation or a complete replacement, we’ll make sure you get the best value, performance, and long-term reliability.
Call ACE Elevators Northern on 01535 600 688 or Request a Free Lift Assessment
Let’s find the smartest solution for your building.

















